Aragon AI vs InstaHeadshots vs HeadshotPro is a close race. All three turn a few selfies into studio-style headshots in under an hour. The real differences are price per photo, refund rules and how much control you get.
One big change first: InstaHeadshots is now Magic Studio. The old site redirects to Magic Studio’s headshot page, so that’s what we compare below.
TL;DR
- Best value for most people: Aragon AI. 60 headshots for $45 and the lowest cost per photo.
- Cheapest way in, and best for teams: HeadshotPro. Starts at $29 and has real team tools.
- Lowest risk: InstaHeadshots, which is now called Magic Studio. You only pay after you see your photos.
- Need print or 4K? HeadshotPro Executive ($59) is the only plan here with 4K downloads.
Quick comparison
| Aragon AI | HeadshotPro | InstaHeadshots (Magic Studio) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $35 | $29 | $59 |
| Headshots | 40 to 100 | 30 to 70 | 50 |
| Fastest delivery | 15 min | 15 min | 15 min |
| Pay before you see? | Yes | Yes | No, pay after |
| Trustpilot | 4.9 (per Aragon) | 4.7 | 5.0 |
Pricing compared, plan by plan
Aragon gives you the most headshots for the money. HeadshotPro has the cheapest entry plan. Magic Studio costs more up front but removes the risk of paying for photos you hate.
| Plan | Price | Headshots | Cost per photo | Delivery |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aragon Basic | $35 | 40 | $0.88 | 45 min |
| Aragon Standard | $45 | 60 | $0.75 | 30 min |
| Aragon Executive | $75 | 100 | $0.75 | 15 min |
| HeadshotPro Basic | $29 | 30 | $0.97 | ~2 hours |
| HeadshotPro Professional | $39 | 50 | $0.78 | ~30 min |
| HeadshotPro Executive | $59 | 70 | $0.84 | ~15 min |
| Magic Studio (from) | $59 | 50 | $1.18 | 15 min |
All plans are one-time payments, not subscriptions. Aragon’s prices above include a “20% off, limited time” deal. Without it, plans list at $44, $56 and $94.
1. Aragon AI: best value per headshot
Pick Aragon if you want lots of options without paying much. The Standard plan is what most buyers choose. Aragon’s own pricing page says 83% pick it.
- Headshots: 40, 60 or 100, depending on plan.
- Outfits and backgrounds: 1 each on Basic, 2 each on Standard, all of them on Executive.
- Resolution: 896 x 1088 px on Basic and Standard. Executive doubles it to 1792 x 2176 px.
- Refund: full refund if you haven’t downloaded your photos, or a free redo.
- Uploads: just a few casual selfies. Aragon sets no fixed number and says quality beats quantity.
- Privacy: your face photos are deleted within 30 days after delivery (unless you’re on a subscription), and Aragon bars its AI providers from training general models on them.
- Teams: Aragon also sells branded team headshots, with prices on the Teams tab of its pricing page.
Watch out: Basic locks you into one outfit and one background. If you want variety, go straight to Standard.
2. HeadshotPro: cheapest start, best for teams
HeadshotPro is the one to pick for a company rollout or a print job. It’s also the cheapest way to test AI headshots at $29.
- Headshots: 30, 50 or 70, plus 6, 26 or 46 edit credits.
- Free redo: only on Professional and Executive, within 14 days.
- 4K downloads: Executive only.
- Teams: about $25.35 per person when you buy 100 credits, with volume discounts from 20% up to 50%. You also get an admin dashboard, branded backdrops and credits that never expire.
- Privacy: selfies and results auto-delete after 30 days. Photos are not used to train AI.
Watch out: the $29 Basic plan takes about 2 hours and has no free redo. For most people, the $39 Professional plan is the smarter buy.
3. InstaHeadshots (now Magic Studio): pay only if you like them
InstaHeadshots rebranded as Magic Studio. Same headshot service, new name. Its big selling point: you create your headshots for free and only pay if you want to keep them.
- Price: from $59 for 50 headshots in 5 looks.
- Uploads: 10 selfies with different backgrounds, angles and lighting.
- Delivery: 15 to 60 minutes, depending on the pack. The Starter pack is the slowest at about an hour.
- Refund: if you get fewer than 4 decent headshots and haven’t downloaded any. Ask within 3 days.
- Extras: changing outfits or backgrounds later costs more.
Watch out: it’s the most expensive per photo here. You’re paying for the safety net.
Refunds, privacy and usage rights
All three let you get your money back, but only before you download. Here’s what each one promises on its own site.
| Refund | Your photos | Usage rights | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aragon AI | Full refund if not downloaded, or a free redo | Deleted within 30 days after delivery, not used to train general AI models | You own them: social, profiles, print |
| HeadshotPro | Money-back guarantee, free redo on Professional and Executive (14 days) | Deleted after 30 days, not used to train AI | See HeadshotPro’s terms |
| InstaHeadshots (Magic Studio) | If fewer than 4 decent headshots and none downloaded, within 3 days | Deleted 30 days after your headshots are made | Full commercial rights |
Which one gives the most realistic results?
No tool wins every time. Your selfies matter more than the brand. All three can over-smooth skin or slightly change your face, and Trustpilot reviewers mention this for each one.
Expect to keep a handful of great shots out of a big batch. That’s normal. It’s why the number of headshots per plan matters.
Get better results with any of them:
- Use recent photos where you look like you do today.
- Mix angles, outfits, backgrounds and lighting.
- Skip filters, sunglasses, hats and group shots.
- Don’t download anything until you’re sure. Downloading can cancel your refund on all three.
Real test results: before and after
Want to see real faces, not marketing samples? These reviewers ran each tool on their own selfies and show the results on camera. Under each video, you’ll also see the official samples each brand shows on its own site, so you can compare the two.
Aragon AI test
HeadshotPro test
InstaHeadshots (Magic Studio) test
Which should you pick?
| If you want… | Pick |
|---|---|
| The most headshots for the money | Aragon AI Standard ($45) |
| The cheapest test run | HeadshotPro Basic ($29) |
| Zero risk before paying | InstaHeadshots / Magic Studio ($59) |
| Print quality or 4K | HeadshotPro Executive ($59) |
| Headshots for a whole team | HeadshotPro Team |
Other options worth a look
BetterPic is the alternative that comes up most in these comparisons. It starts at $35, gives 20 to 120 headshots, and delivers 4K on every plan. Refunds work only within 7 days and before model training starts.
Want more options beyond these? See our list of the best AI headshot generators for professionals.
How we compared
We checked each tool’s official pricing, refund and privacy pages (including Aragon’s privacy policy), plus their Trustpilot profiles, on October 16, 2026. The screenshots above come from those pages on the same day. For real photo results, we picked independent video reviews where people test each tool on their own selfies.
We compared what you get for the money: price, number of headshots, speed, refund rules and photo privacy. Photo quality depends a lot on the selfies you upload, so lean on the refund rules if your first batch misses.
FAQ
Is InstaHeadshots still available?
Yes, under a new name. InstaHeadshots is now Magic Studio. The old instaheadshots.com address redirects to Magic Studio’s headshot page, and the service works the same way.
Is Aragon AI better than HeadshotPro?
For one person, Aragon usually gives more headshots per dollar. HeadshotPro is better for teams, 4K downloads and a cheaper first try at $29. Quality depends mostly on the selfies you upload.
Which AI headshot generator is cheapest?
HeadshotPro Basic at $29 is the lowest price. Per photo, Aragon’s Standard and Executive plans are cheapest at about $0.75 each.
Can I get a refund on AI headshots?
Yes, on all three, but only before you download. Aragon offers a refund or a free redo. HeadshotPro has a money-back guarantee. Magic Studio refunds if you get fewer than 4 decent headshots, within 3 days.
Can I use AI headshots on LinkedIn?
Yes. All three are built for LinkedIn, resumes and company sites. Aragon says you own your AI photos, and Magic Studio gives you full commercial rights.
Verdict
Go with Aragon AI if you’re buying for yourself and want the best value. Choose HeadshotPro for a team, for print, or for the cheapest first try. Choose InstaHeadshots (Magic Studio) if you don’t want to pay until you’re happy.
Whichever you pick, upload varied selfies and check every photo before you hit download.
Sources: Aragon AI pricing, HeadshotPro pricing, Magic Studio headshots, HeadshotPro on Trustpilot, Magic Studio on Trustpilot. This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.